Apart from this commentary I will also include some other quotes from Kant's work that involve lying, or right, that may help clarify and add detail to Kant's...
In his ‘OnaSupposedRighttoLiefrom Philanthropy’ (SRL) Kant makes the astonishing claim that one is not entitled to lie even to save a friend from a murderer.
{"2_edca":{"state":{"logo":{"href":"//yandex.com.tr","isForeign":true},"form":{"action":"/search/","searchLabel":"Bul","hiddenInputs":[{"name":"lr","value":20815}]},"actions":{"advancedSearch":{"checked":false,"ariaLabel":"Gelişmiş arama"},"moreButtonProps":{"ariaLabel":"Daha fazla"},"cbir":{"name":"cbir","label":"Görsele göre arama","infoUrl":"//yandex.ru/promo/photosearch/index?source=landingdesk","isMacOS":false}},"userSection":{"loggedIn":false,"loginProps":{"loginUrl":"https://passport.yandex.com.tr/auth?retpath=%2F&origin=serp_desktop_auth_new","loginText":"Giriş yap","burgerAriaLabel":"Menü"}},"navigation":{"tabs":[{"id":"www","label":"Arama","url":"//yandex.com.tr","params":{"source":"tabbar"},"target":""},{"id":"images","label":"Görsel","url":"//yandex.com.tr/gorsel/search","params":{"text":"[$query]","noreask":"[$noreask]","nomisspell":"[$nomisspell]","parent-reqid":"[$reqid]","from":"tabbar"}},{"id":"video","label":"Video","url":"//yandex.com.tr/video/search","params":{"text":"[$query]","noreask":"[$noreask]","parent-reqid":"[$reqid]","from":"tabbar"}},{"id":"maps","label":"Haritalar","url":"//yandex.com.tr/harita","params":{"text":"[$query]","source":"serp_navig"}},{"id":"translate","label":"Çeviri","url":"//ceviri.yandex.com.tr","params":{"text":"[$query]","from":"tabbar"}}],"selectedTabId":"www"},"context":{"query":"On a Supposed Right to Tell Lies from Benevolent Motives Иммануил Кант книга","reqid":"1728480475564583-7806399093018838592-balancer-l7leveler-kubr-yp-klg-154-BAL","lr":"20815","counters":{"type":"b","data":{"$header":"0_f28cz000","logo":"0_f28cz001","login":"0_f28cz003","usermenu":"0_f28cz004","market-cart":"0_f28cz006","more-button":"0_f28cz007","cbir":"0_f28cz008","$navigation":"0_f28cz009","item":"0_f28cz00i","tab-www":"0_f28cz00b","tab-images":"0_f28cz00d","tab-video":"0_f28cz00f","tab-maps":"0_f28cz00h","tab-translate":"0_f28cz00j"}}},"loggedIn":false,"baobab":{"parentNode":{"context":{"genInfo":{"prefix":"0_f28cw01-0-1"},"ui":"desktop","service":"web","reqid":"1728480475564583-7806399093018838592-balancer-l7leveler-kubr-yp-klg-154-BAL","fast":{"name":"header-desktop"}}}}},"type":"header-desktop"},"2_f28c0":{"state":{"advAjax":{"subtype":"premium_ajax","shown":"eyJwcmVtaXVtIjpbXX0="},"baobab":{"parentNode":{"context":{"genInfo":{"prefix":"2_f28cw0e-0-1"},"ui":"desktop","service":"web","reqid":"1728480475564583-7806399093018838592-balancer-l7leveler-kubr-yp-klg-154-BAL","fast":{"name":"adv","subtype":"return_ajax"}}}}},"type":"adv","subtype":"return_ajax"},"2_f28c1":{"state":{"linksGroups":[{"type":"geo","links":[{"label":"Columbus","title":"Columbus","url":"//yandex.com.tr/tune/geo","logNode":{"name":"region"},"target":"_self","a11yLabel":"Bölgeniz Columbus","needRetpath":true}]},{"type":"searchengines","links":[{"label":"Google","url":"//www.google.com.tr/search?ie=UTF-8&q=On%20a%20Supposed%20Right%20to%20Tell%20Lies%20from%20Benevolent%20Motives%20%D0%98%D0%BC%D0%BC%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%83%D0%B8%D0%BB%20%D0%9A%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%82%20%D0%BA%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B3%D0%B0","logNode":{"name":"link","attrs":{"type":"google"}},"target":"_blank"},{"label":"Bing","url":"//www.bing.com/search?q=On%20a%20Supposed%20Right%20to%20Tell%20Lies%20from%20Benevolent%20Motives%20%D0%98%D0%BC%D0%BC%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%83%D0%B8%D0%BB%20%D0%9A%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%82%20%D0%BA%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B3%D0%B0","logNode":{"name":"link","attrs":{"type":"bing"}},"target":"_blank"}]},{"type":"feedback","links":[{"label":"Hata bildir","logNode":{"name":"feedback","attrs":{"behaviour":{"type":"dynamic"}}}}]},{"type":"settings","links":[{"label":"Ayarlar","url":"//yandex.com.tr/tune/search","logNode":{"name":"settings"},"target":"_self","needRetpath":true}]},{"type":"company","links":[{"label":"Hakkımızda","url":"https://company.yandex.com.tr","logNode":{"name":"about"},"target":"_blank"},{"label":"Ticari teklifler","url":"/search/direct?text=On%20a%20Supposed%20Right%20to%20Tell%20Lies%20from%20Benevolent%20Motives%20%D0%98%D0%BC%D0%BC%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%83%D0%B8%D0%BB%20%D0%9A%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%82%20%D0%BA%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B3%D0%B0&filters_docs=direct_cm","logNode":{"name":"commercial"},"target":"_blank"},{"label":"Kariyer","url":"//yandex.com.tr/jobs/?utm_source=serp_turkie&utm_medium=footerlink&utm_content=career","logNode":{"name":"vacancy"},"target":"_blank"},{"label":"Kullanım lisansı","url":"//yandex.com.tr/legal/termsofuse/","logNode":{"name":"license"},"target":"_blank"},{"label":"Gizlilik Politikası","url":"//yandex.com.tr/legal/confidential/","logNode":{"name":"confidential"},"target":"_blank"}],"a11yHidden":true}],"reportFeedbackProps":{"feature":"Подвал","title":"Hata bildir","checkBoxLabels":[]},"isSearchApp":false,"hasExtralinks":true,"limitingSelector":".AliceFabButton","baobab":{"parentNode":{"context":{"genInfo":{"prefix":"2_f28cw0g-0-1"},"ui":"desktop","service":"web","reqid":"1728480475564583-7806399093018838592-balancer-l7leveler-kubr-yp-klg-154-BAL"}}}},"type":"serp-footer"},"2_f28c2":{"state":{"conditionLoadList":{"marketCart":false,"highchartsHighstock":false,"advProductGallery":false,"musicPlayer":false,"ecomRates":false,"photoViewer":false,"easterEggModal":false,"easterEggPlusGamesModal":false,"futurisFeedbackLoader":false,"darkmodeChangeDrawer":true},"reportFeedbackBaseProps":{"initEmail":"","metaFields":{"userAgent":"Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)","userTestids":"1111484,1066210,186144,1124847,1107403,1111663,1118175,1130023,1128740,1121116,1121142,1127139,1125706,1089202,1113827,1126266,1129818,1131292,123830,936724,1129876,1118344,1127761,182559,1114430,1115039,1128976,1123168,1132017,1124871,1124682,1123127,1128779,1123305,1120061,1123730,1131636,1127540,1126415,1125105,263461,255406,1122083,996794,1119848,1130054,1129212,1129206,332148,1128592,151171,1130010,1029969,287509,338390,781253,1125325,1122265,1131687,1126638,1128919,1128873,1083581,1117284,1097894,681841","yandexuid":"9230886141728480475","uid":"0","queryText":"On a Supposed Right to Tell Lies from Benevolent Motives Иммануил Кант книга","reqid":"1728480475564583-7806399093018838592-balancer-l7leveler-kubr-yp-klg-154-BAL","searchSlices":["drawer_search_slice_education"],"userRegionName":"Columbus","userRegionId":"20815","isChildAccount":false}},"extralinksPopupProps":{"abuseLink":"https://twitter.yandex.com.tr/search/abuse?sign=dcbe89e48e51560571dabc64f1334390&keyno=0"},"isLoggedIn":false,"userMenuDialogProps":{"flag":"skin,feedback","host":"yandex.com.tr","lang":"tr","project":"serp","queryParams":{"utm_source":"search"},"retpath":"https%3A%2F%2Ftwitter.yandex.com.tr%2Fsearch%2F%3Ffilters_docs%3Ddirect_cm%26lr%3D20815%26text%3DOn%2Ba%2BSupposed%2BRight%2Bto%2BTell%2BLies%2Bfrom%2BBenevolent%2BMotives%2B%25D0%2598%25D0%25BC%25D0%25BC%25D0%25B0%25D0%25BD%25D1%2583%25D0%25B8%25D0%25BB%2B%25D0%259A%25D0%25B0%25D0%25BD%25D1%2582%2B%25D0%25BA%25D0%25BD%25D0%25B8%25D0%25B3%25D0%25B0%26ncrnd%3D39576","tld":"com.tr"},"baobab":{"parentNode":{"context":{"genInfo":{"prefix":"2_f28cw0h-0-1"},"ui":"desktop","service":"web","reqid":"1728480475564583-7806399093018838592-balancer-l7leveler-kubr-yp-klg-154-BAL","fast":{"name":"lazy-load"}}}}},"type":"lazy-load"}}